Is Vinegar the Best Rust Remover? Let’s Find Out.


Is Vinegar the Best Rust Remover? Let’s Find Out.

(Image: Screenshot from best rust remover video)

Rust removal is something most folks have to deal with at some point in time, and our pal Steve recently got a new ultrasonic cleaner and decided to do some experiments to discover the best rust remover to use with it. He compiled a really long list of things to try, and here they are:

  1. Water
  2. OxiClean
  3. Muriatic acid
  4. Battery acid
  5. Acetone
  6. Acetone mixed with ATF
  7. ATF
  8. Methyl hydrate
  9. Ethanol
  10. Coca-Cola
  11. White vinegar
  12. White vinegar mixed with salt
  13. CLR
  14. Carpet shampoo
  15. Paint thinner
  16. Degreaser
  17. Evaporust
  18. TSP (trisodium phophate)
  19. Borax
  20. Dawn dish soap
  21. Simple Green
  22. Drain opener (like Drano or Liquid Plumb’r)
  23. Toilet bowl cleaner
  24. Gasoline
  25. Hydrogen peroxide
  26. WD-40
  27. Diesel fuel
  28. Brake fluid
  29. Bleach
  30. Lemon juice
  31. Orange juice
  32. Ammonia

Before telling viewers the list above, Steve asks viewers to post their guesses in the comments about which one is the best rust remover according to his tests… and he adds this:

“I’ll tell ya right now: You’re all wrong!”

Steve doesn’t fill his ultrasonic cleaner with every one of these substances — he’d have to be filthy rich! Instead, he places a rusty object in a ziploc bag with some of the liquid to be tested, and puts the bag into the cleaner, which is filled with water. The bag floats up top and the ultrasonic waves do their work right through the bag.

Each substance was tried for ten minutes, because who wants to wait hours when they could wait minutes? He tells us the vast majority of the things he tried did pretty much nothing to remove rust in those ten minutes. So c’mon Steve, stop teasing us. What’s the best rust remover?

Here are his top 4:

  • Evaporust
  • CLR
  • Toilet bowl cleaner
  • White vinegar

I have used Evaporust before, and it’s pretty great for removing rust — and no ultrasonic cleaner is required. It’s also environmentally friendly and can be reused many times — but it’s expensive.

Also, be aware that any time you use rust remover on gun parts, you will also remove the bluing (because bluing is a form of rust).

I have also used white vinegar to remove rust, most notably from inside gas tanks. It too works well, but may take quite a while when used on its own (without an ultrasonic cleaner). It’s cheap and reusable, but you must remember to neutralize the acid once the rust is gone (baking soda works well for this).

Back to the video: Steve’s winner is Lysol Power toilet bowl cleaner!

No kidding. Out of all those things he tested, toilet cleaner won the day. Who knew?

I might have to try it on some old tractor parts now. In the meantime, enjoy the video.

Avatar Author ID 61 - 1467059357

Editor & Contributing Writer Russ Chastain is a lifelong hunter and shooter who has spent his life learning about hunting, shooting, guns, ammunition, gunsmithing, reloading, and bullet casting. He started toting his own gun in the woods at age nine and he's pursued deer with rifles since 1982, so his hunting knowledge has been growing for more than three and a half decades. His desire and ability to share this knowledge with others has also grown, and Russ has been professionally writing and editing original hunting & shooting content since 1998. Russ Chastain has a passion for sharing accurate, honest, interesting hunting & shooting knowledge and stories with people of all skill levels.

Read More